Auction & Sale Report
Melbourne November 15th Weekend 2008
James Covered Auctions Clearance rate: 38% from 13 properties to auction
CLEARANCE RATES IN PERCENT
WEEKEND AUCTIONS AT A GLANCE
Market Insight
Adam's Architecture

Adam Woledge
0413 318 079
Registered Architect & Principal Buyer Agent
Downsizing in Brighton - 15 Lindsay Street
Even in this tough market, properties are still selling – even (although not that many) ones that need renovation, if the land content (ie size and position) is good.
This property sold under the hammer on the weekend for a strong price within the quoted range.
Positives
Location, a leafy street with many pretty houses of genuine character – close to Church Street
North-facing rear
Pretty house with genuine character and very good bones
Negatives
Renovation work required
Construction risk
Holding costs
One could extend up to the rear, but this may result in a compromised design and involve angst/consent from adjoining neighbours.
A better solution may be to keep everything on the one level, with design that is modern internally, yet externally blends seamlessly with the original house.
This design maintains good flow and would suit an elderly couple wanting to remain in Brighton or a young couple wanting a comfortable entry point into Brighton. Modern kitchen, bathroom, ensuite areas are well complemented by an open-plan living area, connected very well to the private open space.
Auctions We Attended
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 11 Rookwood Street | Large Houses | 3,000,000 |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| 3,250,000 | ||
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Steve Abbott | Jellis Craig | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| PASSED IN |
OUR COMMENTS
"A fantastic home - built with real passion and attention to detail. North-facing rear captures sunlight and also amazing views. Although a very good crowd of around 180 people, this did not result in a single bid and was a very quiet auction indeed. "
Adam Woledge
0413 318 079
Registered Architect & Principal Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 17 Byron Street | Medium Houses | 1,800,000 |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| 1,650,000 | ||
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| David Hart | Buxton | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| PASSED IN |
OUR COMMENTS
"No bids from the 30 people present for this quiet tidy, north-facing rear home in Brighton."
Mal James
0408 107 988
Principal Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 16 Glencairn Avenue | Medium Houses | 1,000,000+ |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| David Hart | Buxton | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| BOUGHT BEFORE |
OUR COMMENTS
"Sold beforehand; believed to be within the quote range."
Mal James
0408 107 988
Principal Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 7 Outlook Drive | Medium Houses | 850,000 |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Glen Coutinho | Hocking Stuart | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| BOUGHT |
OUR COMMENTS
"Was surprised by depth of bidding, as may have been auctioneer Glen Coutinho, who conducted his usual quick and professional auction. Four bidders in total, with three over the reserve of $800,000. Strong result."
Mal James
0408 107 988
Principal Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 48 Melville Street | Small Houses | 1,350,000 |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| Undisclosed | ||
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Maurice Di Marzio | Jellis Craig | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| PASSED IN |
OUR COMMENTS
"After auctioneer Maurice DiMarzio opened this at $1.2 million and followed with a string of vendor bids to $1.275 million, this was passed in to one bidder at $1.28 million. Located in a tightly held pocket, this house should sell soon. "
Adam Woledge
0413 318 079
Registered Architect & Principal Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 5 Elphin Grove | Medium Houses | 1,500,000 |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Richard Spratt | Jellis Craig | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| BOUGHT AFTER |
OUR COMMENTS
"A reasonably quiet auction here in front of 45 people - passed in to one bidder at $1.45 million after opening on a vendor bid of $1.4 million - this has a lot going for it if someone has the energy for the major renovation ahead. Sold after for $1.51 million."
Adam Woledge
0413 318 079
Registered Architect & Principal Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 8 Kooyongkoot Road | Land Only | 3,000,000 |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| 2,500,000 | ||
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Justin Long | Jellis Craig | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| PASSED IN |
OUR COMMENTS
"Good crowd of 70 people saw auctioneer Justin Long open with a vendor bid at $2 million. One bid of $2.05 million resulted in a pass-in way below the expected price. We await news."
Grant Atkinson
0412 545 334
Licensed Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 13 Isabella Grove | Large Houses | 1,500,000 |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Paul Castran | Castran Gilbert | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| BOUGHT |
OUR COMMENTS
"Auctioneer Paul Castran ran a very professional auction, taking 50 bids in a long drawn-out process. Crowd 50 - 5 bidders. This was well below what it sold for early in the year and in line with our stated $1m+ market drops."
Grant Atkinson
0412 545 334
Licensed Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 45 First Avenue | Large Houses | 2,100,000 |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| 1,995,000 | ||
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Nick Elmore | Jellis Craig | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| PASSED IN |
OUR COMMENTS
"A quality product with north-facing tranquil rear yard. Did not attract a single bid, but expect this to sell soon, as it is very good."
Adam Woledge
0413 318 079
Registered Architect & Principal Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 48 Finch Street | Land Only | |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| Undisclosed | ||
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Warwick Anderson | RT Edgar | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| PASSED IN |
OUR COMMENTS
"50 people present to see Warwick Anderson pass in property to a bidder at $1.109 million. Should sell."
Mal James
0408 107 988
Principal Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 323 Richardson Street | Medium Houses | 2,000,000+ |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Damian O'Sullivan | Bennison Mackinnon | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| BOUGHT AFTER |
OUR COMMENTS
"Auctioneer Damian O'Sullivan started with a vendor bid of $1.9 million, followed by a buyer bid of $1.91 million, followed by a vendor bid of $2 million, followed by some crowd chuckles from the 50 present - passed in, then sold."
Mal James
0408 107 988
Principal Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 47 Millswyn Street | Small Houses | 2,250,000 |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| Undisclosed | ||
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Gowan Stubbings | Kay & Burton | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| PASSED IN |
OUR COMMENTS
"Vendor opening bid at the quote. No response from the crowd of 80 present. Very, very quiet."
Mal James
0408 107 988
Principal Buyer Agent
| POSITION | PROPERTY | PRICE/QUOTE |
| 11 Highgate Hill | Medium Houses | 4,000,000 |
| OPENING BID | RESERVE | LAST BID |
| Undisclosed | ||
| AUCTIONEER | AGENCY | AUCTION VIBE |
| Andrew Macmillan | Bennison Mackinnon | |
| CROWD | BIDDERS | RESULT |
| PASSED IN |
OUR COMMENTS
"Auctioneer Andrew Macmillan opened with a $3.8 million vendor bid to a minute crowd of 30. No action. Further vendor bid and passed in at $4 million. Signs were not positive for an immediate sale; however, this is a wonderfully located home and we would not be surprised to see a sale in the not-too-distant future."
Grant Atkinson
0412 545 334
Licensed Buyer Agent
Million Dollar Sales
All results can be found at REIVAberfeldie
PI 2B May St Rend 7rm 300sqm $1,050,000 res $1,145,000 Barry Plant
Albert Park
S 203 Bridport WB 5rm 225sqm undisc Hocking Stuart
Armadale
S 7 Erskine St B 10rm 9242sqm $2,685,000 Marshall White and Co
PI 39A Armadale St B 6rm 300sqm $1,600,000 VB res $1,700,000 Marshall White and Co
SB 56 Adelaide St 7rm undisc Kay and Burton
Aspendale
PI 42 Bowman St BV 7rm 532sqm $2,000,000 VB res $2,300,000 Hocking Stuart
Balaclava
Commercial:
S 141 Carlisle St retail $1,476,000 Morleys Elwood
Balwyn
S 2 Elliott Av BV 8rm 607sqm $1,105,000 Christopher Russell
PS Pryton Ct $1,075,000 Hocking Stuart
Balwyn North
S 8 Abassia St BV 11rm 697sqm undisc Noel Jones
PI 11 Rookwood St BV 12rm 646sqm $2,850,000 VB res $3,250,000 Jellis Craig
Beaumaris
S 74 Tramway Pde BV 10rm 865sqm $1,720,000 Buxton
PI 8 Surf Av BV 9rm 565sqm $1,300,000 VB res $1,400,000 Hodges
PI 92 Tramway Pde Rend 6rm 372sqm $1,200,000 VB lo $1,250,000 res $1,290,000 Buxton
Blackburn
SB 53-55 Williams Rd BV 5rm 1887sqm $1,155,000 Barry Plant
SB 55 Williams Rd B 6rm 1887sqm undisc Barry Plant
Brighton
S 21 Holmwood Av Rend 7rm 320sqm undisc Buxton
PI 17 Byron St B 7rm 701sqm $1,550,000 VB res $1,650,000 Buxton
PS Cochrane St WB 8rm 433sqm $1,200,000 Hodges
PS Hampton St $426,000 Hocking Stuart
PS Orchard St WB 5rm 439sqm $1,200,000 Hodges
Brighton East
S 181 Were St B 8rm 670sqm $1,150,000 Hocking Stuart
PI 14 Baird St BV 7rm s/div $1,400,000 VB res $1,465,000 Hodges
SB 16 Glencairn Av BV 8rm 773sqm $1,075,000 Buxton
Camberwell
PI 35 Lynden St WB 7rm 693sqm $1,050,000 VB res $1,185,000 Marshall White and Co
Carlton North
S 476 Canning St B 7rm 180sqm $1,300,000 Hocking Stuart
Caulfield north
PI 1A Craddock Av v/land 674sqm $1,050,000 VB res undisc Gary Peer and Associates
S 270 Orrong Rd B 7rm 790sqm undisc Gary Peer and Associates
Clifton Hill
PI 31 Gray St WB 5rm 10mx45m $1,125,000 VB res $1,210,000 Nelson Alexander
Collingwood
SB 8/93 Oxford St B 4rm strata $1,025,000 Jellis Craig
Elsternwick
S 18 Gardenia Rd WB 9rm 650sqm $1,188,000 Hocking Stuart
Elwood
PI 249 Brighton Rd B 7rm 765sqm $1,000,000 VB res $1,200,000 Marshall White and Co
Essendon
PI 19 Brunel St WB 8rm 565sqm $960,000 lo $1,010,000 res $1,070,000 Paul Mcdonald RE
PI 55 Robb St B 7rm 530sqm $1,460,000 VB res $1,510,000 Nelson Alexander
Fairfield
PI 78 Park Cr 5rm 350Sqm $1,200,000 lo $1,250,000 res undisc Thomson
PI 117 Rathmines BV $1,800,000 VB lo $1,800,000 res $2,000,000 Nelson Alexander
Fitzroy North
PI 554 Rae St WB 5rm 500sqm $1,400,000 VD res undisc Hocking Stuart
Flinders
PS The Esplanade B 10rm 1241sqm $2,250,000 Kay & Burton
Footscray
Commercial:
PI 61-63 Leeds St commercialibuilding: 200sqm land: 100sqm $1,300,000 VB res $1,500,000 Burnham Footscray
Footscray West
PI 350-354 Somerville Rd v/land 2600sqm $1,300,000 VB res $1,450,000 Meallin RE Footscray
Glen iris
SO 10 Irymple Av WB 6rm 843sqm $1,290,000 Bennison Mackinnon
SO 21 Vernon St BV 9rm 686sqm undisc Marshall White & Co
PI 32 Grandview Rd B 10rm 859sqm $1,675,000VB res $1,785,000 Bennison Mackinnon
Ps Dillon Gr 8rm 600sqm $1,050,000 Jellis Craig
Hampton
PI 16 Orlando St WB 7rm $1,100,000 VB res $1,165,000
PI 51 Earlsfield Rd WB 9rm 766sqm $1100000 VB res $1,250,000 Hocking Stuart
PI 75 Thomas St B 6rm 575sqm $950,000 VB res $1,025,000 Hodges
Hawthorn
SO 13 Isabella Gr 9rm 750sqm $1,675,000 Castran Gilbert
SO 5 Elphin Gr B 11rm 911sqm $1,510,000 Jellis Craig
PI 48 Melville St WB 6rm 334 sqm $1,280,000 lo $1,300,000 res undisc Jellis Craig/Marshall
PI 8 Kooyongkoot Rd BV 9rm 1067sqm $2,050,000 lo $2,200,000 res $2,500,000 Jellis Craig
PI 20 The Boulevard B 6rm 666sqm $950,000 VB res $1,050,000 Noel Jones
S 302 Barkers Rd retail land: 203sqm $1,005,000 Teska Carson
Commercial:z
S 302 Barkers Rd retail land: 203sqm $1,005,000 Teska Carson
Ivanhoe
PI 148 Waterdale Rd BV 7rm 754sqm $1,010,000 VB res $1,080,000 Miles RE
Ivanhoe East
PI 169 Lower Heidelberg Rd BV 5rm 216sqm $1,720,000 VB res $1,820,000 Hocking Stuart
PI 26 Charteris Dr B 9rm 678sqm $1,220,000 VB res $1,350,000 Jellis Craig
Kew
S 17 Ridgeway Av B 9rm 740sqm undisc Jellis Craig
S 3 Wiltshire Dr B 7rm strata $1,120,000 Jellis Craig
PI 45 First Av BV 10rm 648sqm $1,875,000 VB res $1,995,000 Jellis Craig
PI 70 Mount St v/land 854sqm $1,600,000 VB res $1,700,000 Jellis Craig
Kew East
S 41 Munro St B 6rm 1010sqm $1,190,000 Jellis Craig
Lower Plenty
PS Rosehill Rd B 6385sqm $2,010,000 Morrison Kleeman
Malvern East
PI 48 Finch St B 6rm 594sqm $1,109,000 res undisc Marshall White and Co/RT Edgar
PI 6 Nyora St WB 7rm 756sqm $1,250,000 VB res $1,375,000 Marshall White and Co
Melbourne
Commercial:
PIlS358-360fLtBCollinseSt1lcommercialq$4,950,000uKnightzFrankj
Middle Park
S 323 Richardson St B 7rm 371sqm undisc Bennison Mackinnon
Moonee Ponds
PS Robinson St WB 6rm 456sqm $1,000,000 Paul Mcdonald RE
Moorabool
PI 300 Ballan-Geelong Rd B 9rm $1,100,000 VB res $1,350,000 Charles Stewart & Co
Narre Warren North
PS Fontaine Tce BV $1,050,000 Barry Plant
Plenty
PS Bunyip Ct B 9rm 1214sqm $1,265,000 Morrison Kleeman
Prahran
PS Alfred St $1,035,000 Hocking Stuart
Sandringham
PI 110 Beach Rd WB 9rm 705sqm $1,750,000 VB res $1,875,000 Hocking Stuart
PI 6A Cowper St Rend 7rm s/div $1,000,000 VB lo $1,100,000 res $1,250,000 Buxton
South Yarra
PI 3A Affleck St 6rm 199sqm $1,200,000 VB res $1,500,000 Castran Gilbert
PI 47 Millswyn St B 7rm $2,250,000 VB res undisc Kay and Burton
St Kilda
S 17 Lambeth Pl B 6rm 400sqm $1,098,000 Kay and Burton
St Kilda East
PI 36 Elm Gr WB 6rm 440sqm $1,150,000 VB res $1,250,000 Century 21 Wilson Pride
Surrey Hills
S 6 Pembroke St BV 10rm 1131sqm undisc Noel Jones
PI 11 Guildford Rd BV 8rm 585sqm $1,350,000 VB res $1,460,000 Marshall White and Co
PI 754 Canterbury Rd B 8rm 1083sqm $1,140,000 VB lo $1,175,000 res undisc Hocking Stuart
Templestowe
S 45 O'briens La B 8rm 4040sqm $1,075,000 Barry Plant
Templestowe Lower
PI 12 Dellfield Dr $1,000,000 VB res undisc Ray White Manningham
Toorak
PI 11 Highgate Hill B 6rm 864sqm $4,000,000 VB res undisc Bennison Mackinnon
PI 4 Matthews Ct B 8rm 594sqm $1,400,000 VB res $2,100,000 Marshall White and Coj
SB 8 Denham Pl 8rm 520sqm undisc
West Melbourne
PI 230 Stanley St B 7rm $1,000,000 VB res $1,100,000 Nelson Alexander
| Head Office 36 Wilson Street Brighton 3186 Ph: 03 9591 0199 |
James Home Ratings 313 Glenferrie Road Malvern 3144 Ph: 03 9804 3133 |
Hawthorn office opening late '08. |
James Home Ratings
Large Houses
| 112 St Georges Road, TOORAK (TO BE RATED) |
| 6 Haverbrack Avenue, MALVERN (TO BE RATED) |
| 15 Glendearg Grove, MALVERN (708/1000) |
| 11 Gould Street, BRIGHTON (828/1000) |
| 506 Orrong Road, ARMADALE (TO BE RATED) |
Medium Houses
| 41 Victoria Road North , MALVERN (TO BE RATED) |
| 20 Egerton Road, ARMADALE (TO BE RATED) |
| 19 Rose Street, BENTLEIGH (TO BE RATED) |
| 6 Heaton Avenue, GLEN IRIS (TO BE RATED) |
| 44 McKinley Avenue, MALVERN (TO BE RATED) |
Small Houses
| 74 Page Street, ALBERT PARK (668/1000) |
| 78 Bridport Street, ALBERT PARK (660/1000) |
| 63 Malin Street, KEW (642/1000) |
| 34 Millswyn Street, SOUTH YARRA (681/1000) |
| 48 Melville Street, HAWTHORN (704/1000) |
Land Only
| 11 Tyndall Street, SURREY HILLS (TO BE RATED) |
| 253 Waverley Road, MALVERN EAST (TO BE RATED) |
| 103 Mathoura Road, TOORAK (660/1000) |

We are government licensed Buyer Agents.
Weekly Market Reports
November 15th Weekend
38% from 13 auctions
54% from 704 auctions




































Our newsletter reports on the state of the Melbourne Real Estate market.